Easy Homemade Yogurt! Making It Perfect Every Time

by Suzan Ferreira
Easy Homemade Yogurt! Making It Perfect Every Time bowl of yogurt and granola in bowl

Homemade yogurt is easy to make, healthy and deliciously thick!  It may sound like making your own is intimidating, but it’s really very easy.  With these simple ingredients, you will enjoy a thick, Greek-style yogurt filled with probiotic richness without all the unwanted added additives.


This post may contain affiliate links at no additional cost to you.  By making your purchases through the links on this website, IMSL may make a small percentage at no direct cost to you. IMSL only promotes products we use & truly believe in. Please refer to my Privacy & Disclosures for further information. IMSL thanks you for your support!

This failproof method of making homemade yogurt takes little time, uses few ingredients, and results in a thick, greek like yogurt.  It all starts with quality ingredients.  I highly recommend using local, organic ingredients whenever possible, but any storebought brand of whole milk will work.  I am blessed to have access to organic raw milk at a local farm that we purchase every week. 

Raw Milk For Easy To Make Yogurt


See that wonderful heavy cream line on the top of the jar?  YUM!  The cream adds to the end result of the yogurts thickness as well as wonderful rich flavor.  I know, many of you are like “whole milk”?  What about the calories?  What about eating a low-fat diet?  There are numerous studies recently that have debunked the theory that low-fat is the way to go.  In fact, just the opposite.  One 22 year study published in “The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition” showed that:

Long-term exposure to circulating phospholipid pentadecanoic, heptadecanoic, or trans-palmitoleic acids was not significantly associated with total mortality or incident CVD among older adults. High circulating heptadecanoic acid was inversely associated with CVD and stroke mortality and potentially associated with higher risk of non-CVD death.

Check out our Microgreens at True Leaf Market

What does that mean?  Basically, the people in this long-term study that had high circulating levels of dairy-related fatty acids were less likely to die of heart disease than those with lower levels.   Personally, I have found that by eating whole foods as well as whole-fat foods, I eat less as it takes little to satisfy me.

Don’t have access to organic raw milk?  You can use store-bought whole milk.  Caution!  By using any milk other than whole will work but will make a much thinner end result.  This can also be made without using powdered milk.  But, again, the end result will not be as rich tasting.


There are many methods of making yogurt.  This is the method I have used for many years and is an easy one to follow without having to purchase any additional equipment.  So how to make this wonderful and easy homemade yogurt?  Here we go and enjoy!

Turn your oven on to 200°F to preheat while making the yogurt mixture.

Making yogurt with powdered milk

In a medium-sized pan, add 2 Qt of whole milk and dissolve 1/2 cup of non-fat dry milk powder if using (I recommend it).  I have doubled the original recipe for this tutorial.  Heat slowly on medium heat to 180°F, using an instant-read thermometer or a candy thermometer as I am using,  without disturbing the mixture.  Turn the burner off and let set to cool to 120°F again without disturbing.

Shop Lehman's Now!

While the mixture is cooling (this normally will take approximately 15-20 minutes, less if making only a single batch), I take 2 Qt jars along with 3-4 kitchen towels and placed them on a cast iron pan (optional but recommended as the pan will hold heat longer).  Place in the oven to preheat.

Preheating jars for easy to make homemade yogurt

Once the mixture has reached 120°F, remove 1 Cup of the mixture and place into a bowl along with 1/2 Cup of yogurt starter.  I recommend a plain organic whole fat yogurt of good quality (one with a high count of active cultures) if this is the first time making this recipe.  Stonyfield makes a wonderful organic plain whole fat yogurt.  Again, low-fat versions of yogurt tend to create a thinner end product and also tend to be very high in sugar and additives.  Temper the starter yogurt with the cup of the mixture by mixing well.  Pour back into the mixture in the pan and stir well to combine.

Remove the jars and towels from the oven.  Pour the mixture from the pan and fill both quart jars, screw lids on tightly.  If you don’t already have any of these re-useable storage lids for your mason jars, I highly recommend them!  I snuggly wrap each individual jar with a warmed towel and place back on the warmed cast iron pan.  Cover both jars with 1-2 towels until completely covered and no air can circulate around the jars themselves.

Warmed yogurt filled jars covered with warmed towels

Place back in the oven toward the back where the light is.  Shut the oven OFF and turn the light on.  Leave undisturbed for 8-9 hours.  Remove from the oven and unwrap.  Leave on counter to cool completely prior to placing in the refrigerator for storage.  This yogurt will keep for up to one month.  I can pretty much guarantee it will be long gone before then!

Yogurt Jars Cooling

Once completely cooled to room temperature, open a jar up and enjoy a taste of the most creamy, thick yogurt that you just made for pennies in comparison to store bought brands!

Image of how thick and creamy yogurt is

When making this yogurt with my raw organic whole milk, there will be a cream line on the top as well.  Just stir this cream into the rest of the jar (much to the chagrin of my husband) and you are ready to enjoy!  If using homogenized milk, it will be an even consistency throughout.


If you are not accustomed to eating plain homemade yogurt, you may find this yogurt to be a bit tart at first.  Simply add a little honey, jam or fruit to slightly sweeten to taste.  I personally find that I cannot eat store bought yogurts any longer as there is simply too much sugar.

Check out our Microgreens at True Leaf Market

We love to enjoy over our homemade granola, recipe can be found in our article, “Homemade Healthy Granola”,  with a bit of added fruit and drizzled with our honey. 

Made it?  Love to hear how you are enjoying it!  Feel free to comment below and please be sure to follow on any social media to stay up to date with all the happenings here on the hill!

Love, Light, & Laughter~

Signature of Suzan from It's My Sustainable Life
Easy Homemade Yogurt! Making It Perfect Every Time bowl of yogurt and granola in bowl
Print Pin
5 from 1 vote

Easy To Make Homemade Greek Style Yogurt

A thick, creamy, healthy Greek-style yogurt recipe.
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Author Suzan Ferreira


  • 1 Qt Whole Milk raw organic if possible
  • 1/4 Cup Non-Fat Dry Milk Powder
  • 1/4 Cup Yogurt Starter from previous batches or plain yogurt


  • Preheat oven to 200 F
  • Preheat Qt jar and 2-4 towels in oven while preheating.
  • Combine first two ingredients in pan.  Heat slowly on medium heat to 180 F without stirring or disturbing.
  • Turn Heat off.  Without disturbing, cool to 120 F.
  • Remove 1/2 cup of milk mixture from pan and place in bowl.  Add 1/4 cup yogurt starter and mix.  Return mixture to pan and stir to combine.
  • Remove jars and towels from oven.  Pour mixture from pan into jar and seal closed with lid.
  • Wrap filled jar with several towels and place back in oven in back corner by light.
  • Turn the oven off and turn the oven light on.
  • Leave undisturbed for 8-9 hours.  Remove, unwrap and let cool.
  • Store in refrigerator for up to 1 month


Easy Homemade Yogurt! Making It Perfect Every Time pin for Pinterest

You may also like


Marielle October 2, 2020 - 9:31 pm

I haven’t tried making yogurt yet, but I’ve always wanted. Thanks for sharing this recipe. It feels doable! Pinned! I’m visiting today from the Friendship Friday link up. Have a great weekend!

A spirit of simplicity October 2, 2020 - 9:01 am

I once tried making yoghurt using a yoghurt maker but it came out very thin and not very tasty. I’m going to try this recipe.

Lisa Lombardo September 28, 2019 - 6:16 pm

I love making my own yogurt! Thank you for sharing on Farm Fresh Tuesdays!

Marilyn Lesniak September 27, 2019 - 11:15 pm

5 stars
Thank you for sharing at #OverTheMoon. Pinned and shared. Have a lovely week. I hope to see you at next week’s party too!

Ann @ Live The Old Way September 25, 2019 - 1:28 pm

I am a firm believer in full-fat raw milk too! This is a fantastic recipe, thanks for sharing it with us at the Homestead Blog Hop!

Cheryl Gerou September 19, 2019 - 12:24 pm

This sounds great, I definitely will be trying it. Thanks so much for sharing!

Suzan Ferreira September 21, 2019 - 12:08 pm

Let me know how you enjoy it, Cheryl!

Pamela September 18, 2019 - 1:52 pm

This sounds delicious. We recently went to Finland and our hotel furnished breakfast each morning. They made their own yogurt and filled small canning jars with homemade strawberry jam and then added the yogurt on top. It was delicious. I wanted to bring it home with me. I can’t wait to try this.

Suzan Ferreira September 18, 2019 - 2:14 pm

What a wonderful memory! Please stop back and let us know how you like it!


Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy